Sister Wolf was founded in 1994 by Mary Kay Watson, whose goal was to create a community center for book lovers. Sister Wolf soon became known for its excellent selection of books, book discussion groups, and special events. In 2004, Sally Wizik Wills and Bob Wills purchased Sister Wolf. The store was located in Dorset, just outside Park Rapids, for 20 years.

Jill and Deane Johnson, with inspiration and help from their beagle, Kallie, opened Beagle Books in downtown Park Rapids in 2001. In 2007, the Wills purchased Beagle Books. Their daughter, Jennifer, managed the store. Jen began offering bindery services a few years later and the name of the store was changed to Beagle Books & Bindery.